Updates to the checks of claims by Office of the Prime Minister: new claims, verdicts, report versions and replies. A record, not a score. https://leandergrech.github.io/Mizien/bodies/opm/ 2026-10-11T12:00:00Z Miżien tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-064:2026-10-11:check-started:worker-a-attempt-1-blocked-on-source-malta-business-weekly-5-feb-2026-read-in-full-reports-the-pms-launch-of-the-grand-harbour-revival-plan-in-indirect-speech-communities-particularly-marsa-to-be-prioritised-no-commercial-activities-eliminated-the-fundamental-character-wording-was-not-found-the-maltatoday-original-the-ghrc-press-release-and-the-consultation-document-are-403-to-scripts-needed-the-pms-statement-in-his-own-words-ghrc-release-or-maltatoday-text-and-the-grand-harbour-revival-plan-consultation-pdf 2026-10-11T12:00:00Z

Check started: Worker A, attempt 1: blocked on source. Malta Business Weekly (5 Feb 2026, read in full) reports the PM's launch of the Grand Harbour Revival Plan in indirect speech (communities, particularly Marsa, to be prioritised; no commercial activities eliminated); the 'fundamental character' wording was not found. The MaltaToday original, the GHRC press release and the consultation document are 403 to scripts. Needed: the PM's statement in his own words (GHRC release or MaltaToday text) and the Grand Harbour Revival Plan consultation PDF.. CC-064, Planning & Housing.

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-068:2026-10-10:check-started:worker-b-attempt-1-blocked-on-source-the-record-joins-two-statements-the-prime-ministers-of-22-feb-2022-business-now-quotes-the-best-decision-is-for-this-project-to-stop-at-once-and-the-planning-authoritys-of-3-4-may-2024-relayed-without-quotation-marks-it-has-started-the-process-to-withdraw-policy-smms-04-shelved-is-the-records-paraphrase-needed-the-pas-notice-of-withdrawal-and-its-outcome 2026-10-10T12:00:00Z

Check started: Worker B, attempt 1: blocked on source. The record joins two statements: the Prime Minister's of 22 Feb 2022 (Business Now quotes 'the best decision is for this project to stop at once') and the Planning Authority's of 3-4 May 2024 (relayed without quotation marks: it 'has started the process' to withdraw policy SMMS-04). 'Shelved' is the record's paraphrase. Needed: the PA's notice of withdrawal and its outcome.. CC-068, Planning & Housing.

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-055:2026-10-09:check-started:worker-a-took-the-claim-wording-located-in-readable-outlets-newsbook-tvm-news-lovin-malta-midis-malta-stock-exchange-announcements-read 2026-10-09T12:00:00Z

Check started: Worker A took the claim. Wording located in readable outlets (Newsbook, TVM News, Lovin Malta); MIDI's Malta Stock Exchange announcements read.. CC-055, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Supported (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-055:2026-10-09:exact-wording-found:verbatim-found-abela-quoted-in-quotation-marks-by-newsbook-13-may-2026-historic-moment-by-tvm-news-the-claim-records-text-was-a-headline-summary-and-is-restated 2026-10-09T12:00:00Z

Exact wording found: Verbatim found: Abela quoted in quotation marks by Newsbook (13 May 2026); "historic moment" by TVM News. The claim record's text was a headline summary and is restated.. CC-055, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Supported (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-055:2026-10-09:note:dates-and-amounts-checked-in-tools-cc-055-report-calc-py-data-cc-055-checks-csv-six-acts-searched-on-legislation-mt-for-national-park-none-web-searches-for-a-designation-plan-or-local-plan-change-none-found-log-in-literature-cc-055-notes-md 2026-10-09T12:00:00Z

Note: Dates and amounts checked in tools/cc-055-report/calc.py (data/cc-055/checks.csv). Six Acts searched on legislation.mt for "national park": none. Web searches for a designation, plan or local plan change: none found. Log in literature/CC-055/notes.md.. CC-055, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Supported (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-055:2026-10-09:version-1-0-first-issue:first-issue-verdict-supported-moderate-confidence-pledge-label-not-measurable-as-of-9-oct-2026-pending-right-of-reply 2026-10-09T12:00:00Z

Version 1.0: first issue: First issue. Verdict Supported (moderate confidence); pledge label Not measurable (as of 9 Oct 2026); pending right of reply.. CC-055, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Supported (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-055:2026-10-09:evidence-reviewed 2026-10-09T12:00:00Z

Evidence reviewed. CC-055, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Supported (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-055:2026-10-09:pledge-label-not-measurable:manoel-island-becomes-a-national-park 2026-10-09T12:00:00Z

Pledge label: Not measurable: Manoel Island becomes a national park. CC-055, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Supported (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-027:2026-10-05:check-started:worker-c-attempt-1-blocked-on-source-lovin-malta-paraphrases-the-energy-minister-with-no-quoted-words-the-not-a-lack-of-generation-contrast-the-prime-ministers-statement-and-the-eur-161-million-figure-are-not-in-it-needed-a-dated-primary-text-press-release-hansard-or-interview-transcript 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Check started: Worker C, attempt 1: blocked on source. Lovin Malta paraphrases the Energy Minister with no quoted words; the 'not a lack of generation' contrast, the Prime Minister's statement and the EUR 161 million figure are not in it. Needed: a dated primary text (press release, Hansard or interview transcript).. CC-027, Climate & Energy.

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-027:2026-10-05:note:record-corrected-the-statements-are-from-21-july-2026-tvm-news-interview-with-the-prime-minister-lovin-malta-on-the-energy-minister-not-july-2024-both-report-the-words-as-indirect-speech-a-transcript-of-the-tvm-interview-or-a-press-release-is-still-needed 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Note: Record corrected: the statements are from 21 July 2026 (TVM News interview with the Prime Minister; Lovin Malta on the Energy Minister), not July 2024. Both report the words as indirect speech; a transcript of the TVM interview or a press release is still needed.. CC-027, Climate & Energy.

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-017:2026-10-05:version-1-2:upgrade-1-new-figure-3-a-map-of-marsaxlokk-bay-with-sea-depth-emodnet-mapped-posidonia-meadows-full-resolution-natura-2000-boundaries-and-the-new-land-at-terminal-2-within-1-km-of-the-new-land-the-sea-is-mostly-5-30-m-deep-2-fairness-malta-s-article-17-reports-assess-its-posidonia-beds-as-favourable-overall-2013-2018-2019-2024-stable-the-34-loss-is-mediterranean-wide-section-3-q2-tl-dr-flyer-3-the-prime-minister-s-words-are-now-quoted-in-full-from-lovin-malta-and-tested-as-sub-claim-e-not-tested-ideal-is-not-defined-4-tile-0-4-km-mapped-posidonia-within-1-km-of-the-new-land-the-0-4-km-stays-in-the-text-5-a-bay-wide-sentinel-2-check-for-other-new-land-was-tried-and-dropped-as-not-robust-limitations-verdict-and-confidence-unchanged-maintainer-decision-5-oct-2026-the-map-and-all-seagrass-statistics-now-use-the-emodnet-seabed-habitats-layer-only-cc-by-4-0-whose-maltese-map-2016-is-gridded-at-about-230-m-limitations-mapped-posidonia-lies-next-to-the-new-land-0-01-km-one-grid-cell-72-ha-within-1-km-mapped-meadows-lie-at-11-35-m-in-the-bay-median-26-m-and-21-32-m-within-1-km-median-29-m-tile-and-flyer-card-72-ha-verdict-and-confidence-unchanged 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Version 1.2: Upgrade. (1) New Figure 3: a map of Marsaxlokk Bay with sea depth (EMODnet), mapped Posidonia meadows, full-resolution Natura 2000 boundaries and the new land at Terminal 2; within 1 km of the new land the sea is mostly 5–30 m deep. (2) Fairness: Malta’s Article 17 reports assess its Posidonia beds as favourable overall (2013–2018; 2019–2024, stable); the −34% loss is Mediterranean-wide (section 3, Q2, TL;DR, flyer). (3) The Prime Minister’s words are now quoted in full from Lovin Malta, and tested as sub-claim E (not tested: “ideal” is not defined). (4) Tile “0.4 km” → mapped Posidonia within 1 km of the new land (the 0.4 km stays in the text). (5) A bay-wide Sentinel-2 check for other new land was tried and dropped as not robust (limitations). Verdict and confidence unchanged. Maintainer decision (5 Oct 2026): the map and all seagrass statistics now use the EMODnet Seabed Habitats layer only (CC BY 4.0), whose Maltese map (2016) is gridded at about 230 m (limitations). Mapped Posidonia lies next to the new land (0.01 km, one grid cell), 72 ha within 1 km; mapped meadows lie at 11–35 m in the bay (median 26 m) and 21–32 m within 1 km (median 29 m). Tile and flyer card “72 ha”. Verdict and confidence unchanged.. CC-017, Planning & Housing; verdict so far: Not substantiated (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-017:2026-10-05:evidence-reviewed 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Evidence reviewed. CC-017, Planning & Housing; verdict so far: Not substantiated (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-017:2026-10-05:version-1-1-corrections:corrections-1-the-2019-statement-is-quoted-as-said-least-environmental-damage-a-paraphrase-possible-and-environmentally-safe-cover-tl-dr-sections-2-3-5-6-and-7-sub-claim-c-now-tests-that-wording-2-distance-to-natura-2000-about-1-km-from-the-freeport-measured-from-an-onshore-point-west-of-terminal-2-0-4-km-from-the-new-land-at-terminal-2-to-the-marine-spa-mt0000111-and-0-5-km-to-the-cliff-sites-shortest-distance-to-the-eea-boundaries-data-cc-017-natura2000-distances-csv-tile-1-km-0-4-km-3-three-natura-2000-sites-three-designations-two-of-which-sac-mt0000024-spa-mt0000033-overlap-on-the-same-cliffs-4-flyer-right-of-reply-now-names-the-finance-and-environment-ministries-as-the-report-does-the-34-seagrass-loss-is-labelled-mediterranean-wide-verdict-and-confidence-unchanged 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Version 1.1: corrections: Corrections. (1) The 2019 statement is quoted as said: “least environmental damage” (a paraphrase) → “possible and environmentally safe” (cover, TL;DR, sections 2, 3, 5, 6 and 7); sub-claim C now tests that wording. (2) Distance to Natura 2000: “about 1 km from the Freeport”, measured from an onshore point west of Terminal 2 → 0.4 km from the new land at Terminal 2 to the marine SPA MT0000111 and 0.5 km to the cliff sites (shortest distance to the EEA boundaries; data/cc-017/natura2000_distances.csv); tile “1 km” → “0.4 km”. (3) “Three Natura 2000 sites” → three designations, two of which (SAC MT0000024, SPA MT0000033) overlap on the same cliffs. (4) Flyer: right of reply now names the Finance and Environment ministries, as the report does; the −34% seagrass loss is labelled Mediterranean-wide. Verdict and confidence unchanged.. CC-017, Planning & Housing; verdict so far: Not substantiated (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-016:2026-10-05:version-1-2:upgrade-1-new-figure-1-the-373-berths-split-into-35-plugged-in-by-msc-world-europa-32-by-all-other-ships-and-306-not-plugged-in-beside-the-90-per-connected-liner-and-the-9-of-berth-time-plugged-in-counts-re-read-in-4-and-reconciled-second-hand-former-figures-1-and-2-renumbered-2-and-3-2-msc-world-europa-is-lng-powered-dual-fuel-lng-low-sulphur-marine-gasoil-from-its-owner-s-release-12-section-3-q1-and-limitations-3-plug-in-rates-added-msc-world-europa-35-of-51-calls-all-other-ships-32-of-322-4-tl-dr-point-3-a-tile-306-berths-not-plugged-in-q2-and-flyer-updated-verdict-and-confidence-unchanged-maintainer-decision-5-oct-2026-sub-claim-a-rated-largely-supported-was-plausible-its-evidence-text-and-the-q1-label-updated-to-match 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Version 1.2: Upgrade: (1) New Figure 1: the 373 berths split into 35 plugged in by MSC World Europa, 32 by all other ships and 306 not plugged in, beside the 90% per connected liner and the 9% of berth time plugged in (counts re-read in [4] and reconciled; second-hand); former Figures 1 and 2 renumbered 2 and 3. (2) MSC World Europa is LNG-powered (dual-fuel LNG / low-sulphur marine gasoil), from its owner’s release [12]: Section 3, Q1 and limitations. (3) Plug-in rates added: MSC World Europa 35 of 51 calls, all other ships 32 of 322. (4) TL;DR point 3, a tile (306 berths not plugged in), Q2 and flyer updated. Verdict and confidence unchanged. Maintainer decision (5 Oct 2026): sub-claim A rated Largely supported (was Plausible); its evidence text and the Q1 label updated to match.. CC-016, Air; verdict so far: Misleading (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-016:2026-10-05:evidence-reviewed 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Evidence reviewed. CC-016, Air; verdict so far: Misleading (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-016:2026-10-05:version-1-1-corrections:corrections-1-no-source-gives-the-basis-of-the-90-basis-not-published-infrastructure-malta-s-2020-and-2022-pages-give-it-scoped-to-the-pollution-ships-produce-with-per-liner-cuts-no2-93-pm-92-6-so2-99-6-co2-39-6-10-11-the-2023-page-dropped-the-scope-section-1-2-section-3-the-90-inferred-from-hotelling-s-share-of-co2-7-infrastructure-malta-s-own-per-pollutant-figures-research-kept-as-context-3-sub-claim-d-consistent-figures-vary-eur-33m-2024-launch-37m-phase-1-and-49-9m-whole-project-the-tl-dr-no-longer-attributes-eur-33m-to-the-project-page-which-gives-no-cost-4-tl-dr-point-4-extra-calls-roughly-cancel-the-emissions-saved-states-that-calls-are-calendar-years-uptake-july-july-and-shore-power-was-available-from-july-2024-5-2019-calls-also-given-by-infrastructure-malta-citing-the-nso-what-would-move-it-down-removed-the-clause-saying-no-scoped-wording-was-found-verdict-and-confidence-unchanged 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Version 1.1: corrections: Corrections: (1) “No source gives the basis of the 90%” / “basis not published” → Infrastructure Malta’s 2020 and 2022 pages give it, scoped to the pollution ships produce, with per-liner cuts (NO2 −93%, PM −92.6%, SO2 −99.6%, CO2 −39.6%) [10, 11]; the 2023 page dropped the scope (Section 1). (2) Section 3: the 90% inferred from hotelling’s share of CO2 [7] → Infrastructure Malta’s own per-pollutant figures, research kept as context. (3) Sub-claim D “Consistent” → “Figures vary”: EUR 33m (2024 launch), 37m (phase 1) and 49.9m (whole project); the TL;DR no longer attributes EUR 33m to the project page, which gives no cost. (4) TL;DR point 4 “extra calls roughly cancel the emissions saved” → states that calls are calendar years, uptake July–July and shore power was available from July 2024. (5) 2019 calls: also given by Infrastructure Malta citing the NSO. ‘What would move it down’: removed the clause saying no scoped wording was found. Verdict and confidence unchanged.. CC-016, Air; verdict so far: Misleading (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-012:2026-10-05:evidence-reviewed 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Evidence reviewed. CC-012, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Contradicted (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-012:2026-10-05:version-1-1-corrections:corrections-1-sentinel-2-values-recomputed-with-the-reflectance-offset-boa-add-offset-1000-processing-baseline-04-00-and-later-that-1-0-omitted-which-had-pulled-ndvi-towards-zero-zone-winter-ndvi-before-the-gravel-0-37-0-47-0-38-0-53-0-67-0-57-rest-of-the-park-0-39-0-40-0-65-0-68-winter-2025-26-zone-0-11-0-15-park-0-38-0-68-pre-gravel-summers-about-0-11-about-0-15-winter-ratio-zone-park-0-99-0-88-before-and-0-30-0-23-after-data-cc-012-checks-csv-zone-brightness-now-in-reflectance-may-aug-2025-0-19-0-32-1-0-gave-raw-values-2881-4191-figures-1-and-2-redrawn-figure-1-was-washed-out-zone-2-8-ha-and-scene-set-199-unchanged-2-two-normal-winters-corrected-to-three-2023-2024-2025-level-with-the-rest-of-the-park-changed-to-close-to-3-removed-the-unsourced-statement-that-summer-daze-took-place-in-august-2026-4-what-would-move-it-down-rewritten-contradicted-is-already-the-lowest-rating-5-flyer-the-2-8-ha-zone-was-called-the-same-area-as-momentum-s-2-2-ha-it-is-about-a-quarter-larger-6-layout-removed-a-near-empty-page-verdict-and-confidence-unchanged 2026-10-05T12:00:00Z

Version 1.1: corrections: Corrections: (1) Sentinel-2 values recomputed with the reflectance offset (BOA_ADD_OFFSET −1000, processing baseline 04.00 and later) that 1.0 omitted, which had pulled NDVI towards zero. Zone winter NDVI before the gravel 0.37 / 0.47 / 0.38 → 0.53 / 0.67 / 0.57; rest of the park 0.39–0.40 → 0.65–0.68; winter 2025–26 zone 0.11 → 0.15, park 0.38 → 0.68; pre-gravel summers about 0.11 → about 0.15; winter ratio zone/park 0.99 → 0.88 before and 0.30 → 0.23 after (data/cc-012/checks.csv); zone brightness now in reflectance, May → Aug 2025 0.19 → 0.32 (1.0 gave raw values 2881 → 4191). Figures 1 and 2 redrawn; Figure 1 was washed out. Zone (2.8 ha) and scene set (199) unchanged. (2) “Two normal winters” corrected to three (2023, 2024, 2025); “level with the rest of the park” changed to “close to”. (3) Removed the unsourced statement that Summer Daze took place in August 2026. (4) “What would move it down” rewritten: Contradicted is already the lowest rating. (5) Flyer: the 2.8 ha zone was called the “same area” as Momentum’s 2.2 ha; it is about a quarter larger. (6) Layout: removed a near-empty page. Verdict and confidence unchanged.. CC-012, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Contradicted (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-068:2026-10-04:added-to-the-claims-to-check 2026-10-04T12:00:00Z

Added to the claims to check. CC-068, Planning & Housing.

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-064:2026-10-04:added-to-the-claims-to-check 2026-10-04T12:00:00Z

Added to the claims to check. CC-064, Planning & Housing.

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-055:2026-10-04:added-to-the-claims-to-check 2026-10-04T12:00:00Z

Added to the claims to check. CC-055, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Supported (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-027:2026-10-04:added-to-the-claims-to-check 2026-10-04T12:00:00Z

Added to the claims to check. CC-027, Climate & Energy.

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-017:2026-10-03:added-to-the-claims-to-check 2026-10-03T12:00:00Z

Added to the claims to check. CC-017, Planning & Housing; verdict so far: Not substantiated (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-017:2026-10-03:version-1-0-first-issue:first-issue-right-of-reply-to-the-ministry-for-finance-and-the-ministry-for-the-environment-not-yet-sent 2026-10-03T12:00:00Z

Version 1.0: first issue: First issue. Right of reply to the Ministry for Finance and the Ministry for the Environment not yet sent.. CC-017, Planning & Housing; verdict so far: Not substantiated (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-016:2026-10-03:added-to-the-claims-to-check 2026-10-03T12:00:00Z

Added to the claims to check. CC-016, Air; verdict so far: Misleading (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-016:2026-10-03:version-1-0-first-issue:first-issue-right-of-reply-to-infrastructure-malta-and-transport-malta-not-yet-sent 2026-10-03T12:00:00Z

Version 1.0: first issue: First issue. Right of reply to Infrastructure Malta and Transport Malta not yet sent.. CC-016, Air; verdict so far: Misleading (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-012:2026-10-03:added-to-the-claims-to-check 2026-10-03T12:00:00Z

Added to the claims to check. CC-012, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Contradicted (draft, pending right of reply).

tag:leandergrech.github.io,2026:mizien:CC-012:2026-10-03:version-1-0-first-issue:first-issue-draft-pending-right-of-reply 2026-10-03T12:00:00Z

Version 1.0: first issue: First issue. Draft pending right of reply.. CC-012, Land & Trees; verdict so far: Contradicted (draft, pending right of reply).